Persistent Problem Investigations


When The Problem Keeps Coming Back

A Persistent Problem Investigation starts with a defined problem rather than an assumption about what is causing it.

That problem might involve:

  • Complaints or repeat contact about the same issue that do not reduce, however they are handled
  • A problem that has previously been investigated or addressed but continues to happen
  • Customer journeys that work as intended on paper but produce very different experiences in practice
  • Handovers and escalations, between teams or between AI and people, where information, context or responsibility gets lost
  • Staff struggling with a process or quietly finding ways around it
  • Customers having to chase, repeat information or manage work that should sit with the organisation
  • Measures reporting success while customers describe something quite different
  • Conversational AI that works in demonstrations or expected scenarios but breaks down when real conversations leave the anticipated route
  • A service problem where different parts of the organisation have different explanations for what is causing it

You do not need to know what is causing the problem before getting in touch. Establishing that is the point of the investigation.

The work will depend on the problem and the evidence available, but can include:

  • Reviewing relevant complaints, correspondence, interactions, tickets or other records
  • Reconstructing customer or service histories to understand how a problem developed
  • Identifying recurring patterns, contradictions and accumulated failures
  • Examining repeat contact, customer effort, failed handovers and unresolved issues
  • Comparing intended processes and outcomes with what actually happens
  • Testing human-facing systems and customer journeys where this would help establish what is happening
  • Examining interactions with conversational AI and how systems respond when conversations move outside expected pathways
  • Tracing discrepancies through relevant processes, people, technology, information, measures and decisions
  • Testing possible explanations against the available evidence rather than accepting the first plausible cause
  • Identifying where the evidence supports a conclusion and where something cannot yet be established

The investigation is shaped by the problem. It is not a standard checklist applied regardless of what the evidence shows.

I do not implement the changes I recommend.

Your existing teams, developers, suppliers or other specialists can do that.

Keeping the investigation separate from implementation means the findings are not shaped by what I might subsequently be able to sell you. I have no reason to conclude that you need a new system, a training programme, a technology rebuild or months of additional consultancy unless the evidence actually points in that direction.

The purpose of the investigation is to establish what needs to change, not to manufacture the next piece of work.

Persistent Problem Investigations are diagnostic investigations of human-facing services and systems.

They are not legal advice, regulatory or compliance assessments, technical security or penetration testing, formal policy audits or HR misconduct investigations.

The investigation may consider relevant policies, procedures or organisational requirements where they help explain what happened, but it does not provide legal or regulatory conclusions.

Most defined investigations take around two to four weeks once the necessary access and information are available.

Work is priced according to scope and complexity rather than by the day.

A tightly defined investigation may start at around £5,000. More substantive investigations commonly fall around £7,500–£10,000, with more complex work at £12,500+.

Larger or cross-organisational investigations are scoped separately.

The problem, scope, required access, deliverables and price are agreed before the investigation begins.

If you know something is going wrong but do not yet know why, we can start with an initial conversation about what is happening and whether a Persistent Problem Investigation would be appropriate.

Email team@mindmotive.co.uk.